SIRIANNI YOUTZ SPOONEMORE HAMBURGER
PLLC · Seattle · Since 1981
Our Cases  /  Obesity Discrimination

Obesity discrimination in health coverage.

Obesity is a recognized disability under Washington law. Denying coverage for its treatment simply because it is obesity is discrimination.

We represent patients challenging blanket exclusions of obesity treatment, including GLP-1 medications such as Wegovy and Zepbound. In 2026, the Washington Court of Appeals ruled for our clients in all three of our cases.

3 for 3
Court of Appeals wins for our clients, May 4, 2026
Published
Simonton is binding precedent in Washington
Review denied
Washington Supreme Court, unanimously, October 7, 2026
Next
Discovery, class certification and trial
The Problem

Effective treatment, excluded by design.

Millions of Washingtonians live with obesity, a chronic disease linked to diabetes, heart disease, stroke, sleep apnea and certain cancers.

Effective, FDA-approved prescription medications now exist to treat it. Yet many health plans, including the State of Washington's own employee plans, refuse to cover them. They do so not because a doctor found the treatment unnecessary, but because the plan contains a blanket exclusion for obesity and weight-loss drugs.

Our clients have been denied coverage for GLP-1 medications such as Wegovy, Zepbound, Ozempic and Mounjaro, and for other obesity-related care, under categorical exclusions. Many are paying hundreds of dollars a month out of pocket. Others have gone without treatment their doctors prescribed.

The Law

Three principles at the heart of our cases.

Washington has some of the strongest health insurance anti-discrimination protections in the country.

1

Obesity is a disability.

In Taylor v. Burlington Northern Railroad Holdings (2019), the Washington Supreme Court held that obesity is a disability under the Washington Law Against Discrimination.

2

Plans may not discriminate in benefit design.

RCW 48.43.0128 prohibits health plans from designing or administering benefits in a way that discriminates because of a present or predicted disability or other health condition.

3

Insurance is covered by the WLAD.

The Washington Law Against Discrimination guarantees the right to be free from disability discrimination in insurance transactions.

Put together, a health plan cannot single out a disability and refuse to cover its treatment simply because of what it treats. A plan may still limit coverage for legitimate reasons, such as a treatment being experimental, not medically necessary, or subject to reasonable medical management. But a blanket exclusion that exists "because it had always done so" is not a legitimate reason.

Our Cases

Three putative class actions.

We represent plaintiffs in three putative class actions in Washington courts, each challenging a categorical exclusion of coverage for obesity treatment.

Simonton v. Washington State Health Care AuthorityThurston County Superior Court
Court of Appeals No. 86988-4-I

Jeannette Simonton and Ryan Kelso are state employees enrolled in the Uniform Medical Plan, the self-insured plan the Health Care Authority offers to public employees through PEBB. Each was diagnosed with obesity and prescribed medication to treat it. The plan denied coverage based solely on its exclusion of "prescription drugs for obesity (or weight loss)," an exclusion that applies "even if the services are medically necessary."

Solorio v. Regence BlueShieldKing County Superior Court
Court of Appeals No. 87362-8-I

Luci Solorio is enrolled in a Regence individual or small group plan. Regence denied all coverage for surgery to treat her gastroesophageal reflux disease and hiatal hernia, asserting the surgery was "related to" an earlier bariatric procedure and therefore barred by Regence's blanket obesity exclusion.

Herzog v. Kaiser Foundation Health Plan of WashingtonKing County Superior Court
Court of Appeals No. 87256-7-I

Kurt Herzog challenges Kaiser's exclusion of coverage for prescription drugs to treat obesity in its Washington insured health plans.

Each case seeks relief on behalf of a class of similarly situated plan members, including coverage going forward and reimbursement of costs wrongly denied.

The Rulings

Three wins in the Court of Appeals.

May 4, 2026

Division One rules for our clients in all three cases.

Because it is published, the Simonton opinion is binding precedent in Washington. The court held:

  • Washington's nondiscrimination statute "prohibits excluding coverage for services simply because they are to treat that disability. To do so would discriminate 'because of' that disability."
  • The insurance regulation the health plans relied on, WAC 284-43-5642, sets only minimum "essential health benefits." It does not authorize discriminatory exclusions, and plans must comply with the nondiscrimination requirement independently.
  • Plan members may enforce the nondiscrimination statute through claims for breach of contract and under the Washington Law Against Discrimination.

In Solorio, the court also held that plan members may pursue Consumer Protection Act and good-faith claims based on a discriminatory exclusion. In Herzog, the court reinstated the plaintiff's discrimination and Consumer Protection Act claims.

October 7, 2026

The Washington Supreme Court declines review.

The Health Care Authority asked the Washington Supreme Court to review the Simonton decision. The Supreme Court unanimously denied the petition, leaving the Court of Appeals' published opinion in place.

"What the statute does not permit, and what the ACA was designed fundamentally to reform, is ... a plan's deciding not to deal with a person's disability for no reason other than 'because it had always done so.'"Simonton v. Washington State Health Care Authority, Court of Appeals, Division One
Are You Affected?

You may have a claim.

You may have a claim if you have Washington health coverage and:

  • Your doctor prescribed a GLP-1 medication (such as Wegovy or Zepbound) or another medication to treat obesity, and your plan denied coverage because it excludes weight-loss or obesity drugs;
  • Your plan denied coverage for bariatric surgery, or for later care your plan called "related to" obesity or a prior weight-loss procedure;
  • You are paying out of pocket for obesity treatment because your plan will not cover it; or
  • You went without prescribed treatment because your plan excluded it.
Premera Blue Cross members. We are currently reviewing coverage denials for obesity treatment under Premera Blue Cross plans in Washington. If you are a Premera member and your plan has declined to cover a prescribed GLP-1 medication or other obesity treatment, we would be glad to review your situation at no charge.
This may include members of the Uniform Medical Plan or other PEBB and SEBB plans, Premera Blue Cross, Regence and Kaiser plans, and other Washington insured health plans. Coverage rules differ for self-funded employer plans governed by federal law (ERISA), Medicare and Apple Health (Medicaid), but we are happy to review your situation.
Contact Us

Tell us what happened.

If you believe your health plan has denied coverage for obesity treatment, we would like to hear from you. There is no charge to talk with us about your situation. When you reach out, it helps to have:

  • The name of your health plan and whether you get it through an employer, the State or on your own;
  • Any denial letters or explanations of benefits; and
  • The medication or treatment your doctor prescribed.
Phone
(206) 223-0303
Office
Sirianni Youtz Spoonemore Hamburger PLLC
3101 Western Avenue, Suite 350
Seattle, Washington 98121
Contact us online Please do not send confidential information until we have confirmed that we can assist you.

DisclaimerAttorney advertising. This page provides general information and is not legal advice. Contacting us does not create an attorney-client relationship. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. The cases described are putative class actions; no class has been certified, and the courts have not made a final determination that any exclusion is discriminatory.

© Sirianni Youtz Spoonemore Hamburger PLLC · 3101 Western Avenue, Suite 350, Seattle, WA 98121 · 206.223.0303
Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. This website is attorney advertising.